Thu 16 Nov 2017

Sat 18 Nov 2017
Technische Universität, Senate Room H 1035/1036, Straße des 17. Juni 135, 10623 Berlin // Forum Transregionale Studien, Wallotstr. 14, 14193 Berlin
International Symposium

The Global Power of Private Museums: Arts and Publics – States and Markets

Organized by: Centre for Art Market Studies (TU Berlin), Art Histories and Aesthetic Practices, Forum Transregionale Studien

Convened by: Bénédicte Savoy (Fachgebiet Kunstgeschichte der Moderne, TU Berlin; Collège de France), Dorothee Wimmer (Centre for Art Market Studies, TU Berlin), Julia Voss (2016/17 Fellow of the Wissenschaftskolleg zu Berlin), Hannah Baader (Art Histories and Aesthetic Practices; Kunsthistorisches Institut Florenz), Georges Khalil (Forum Transregionale Studien)

Call for Papers

The history of state or public museums has been the focus of numerous symposiums and publications. Yet astonishingly little research has considered private museums, even though the number of private art museums has risen dramatically over the past two decades. According to the International Council of Museums (ICOM), there are now more private museum spaces in the world than public ones. The majority of these museums are in China, South Korea, the US and Germany, though private museums have been established also in Benin, Brazil, Canada, Denmark, Egypt, India, Japan, Cameroon, Lebanon, Mexico, New Zealand, Norway, Russia, South Africa, among other countries.

Alongside spectacularly designed venues that frequently draw international attention with their exhibition openings, events and acquisition politics, there are museum complexes that have a more regional focus, or operate with limited economic power. Others bridge regional and global concerns, needs or ambitions. At this year's international symposium of the Centre for Art Market Studies at TU Berlin – organized in cooperation with the Forum Transregionale Studien and its research program Art Histories and Aesthetic Practices – participants will be exploring the background, mechanisms and consequences of a phenomenon that may be referred to as the "global power of private museums": 

— What are the reasons behind the current boom in private museums? Are there regional, national or country-specific differences? If so, are these rooted in historical, geographical, political, social, economic or cultural causes?

— Who are the key players (entrepreneurs, private collectors, museum directors, advisors, art dealers, artists, activists, etc.)? And who are the visitors (local public or communities, tourists, children, etc.)?

— What kind of art is acquired, collected, exhibited and, in some cases, resold on behalf of these museums?

— How are the artworks staged, displayed, contextualised and made publicly accessible?

— Do private museums cooperate with, compete with, or take the place of state/public institutions? Are they established for the long term (endowment capital, etc.) or – at least initially – only for the current generation?

— What role do the mechanisms of the contemporary art market play in the development of these collections? How much power do private collectors and their advisors have in this market? In which networks are they actively involved? How do art market institutions respond to this situation? And how does this affect the process of establishing artists and specific art forms?

— What impact do government subsidies such as tax breaks (e.g. on inheritance tax or value-added tax) have on collector's decisions to establish their own museum instead of supporting state/public museums with their own works/collections?

— What additional role is played by foreign cultural policy practices or cross-border incentives of international art exchange programs in this context?

The symposium will focus on privately-funded art museums which are run by individuals, private foundations, associations or companies, with publicly accessible collections in any country or region of the world. The artworks in these collections may range from ancient artefacts to contemporary art.

The conference language is English.


THURSDAY, 16/11/2017
Venue: TU Berlin, Senate Room H 1035/1036, Straße des 17. Juni 135, 10623 Berlin

18:00 Registration

18:15 Welcome and introduction:                                                                                 
Bénédicte Savoy (Berlin / Paris)
Dorothee Wimmer (Berlin)
Julia Voss (Göttingen / Lüneburg)

PANEL DISCUSSION: State/Public/Private Museums: Challenges and Dynamics in a Global Art World

18:30 On the Podium:
Hannah Baader (Florenz / Berlin)
Axel Haubrok (Berlin)
Christiane Lange (Stuttgart)
Sonja Mejcher-Atassi (Beirut / Berlin)

Moderation: Julia Voss (Göttingen / Lüneburg)

19:30 Reception

FRIDAY, 17/11/2017
Venue: TU Berlin, Senate Room H 1035/1036, Straße des 17. Juni 135, 10623 Berlin

10:00 Registration

10:30 Welcome and introduction:
Dorothee Wimmer (Berlin)
Julia Voss (Göttingen / Lüneburg)

SECTION 1: Old Fashion – new Branding? The “Privatization” of Art Museums in Europe
Chair: Dorothee Wimmer (Berlin)

10:45 Anja Grebe (Krems)
The Politics of Public-Private Partnerships: Museum Case Studies from Germany and Austria

11:15 Ronit Milano (Be’er Scheva)
The Power of the Brand: The Economic Instrumentality of Private Museums in France and Ukraine

11:45 Coffee Break

12:00 Waltraud M. Bayer (Wien)
Private Art Museums in post-Soviet Russia

12:30 Kathryn Brown (Loughborough)
The Privatization of Public Museum Culture and the Future of Art History

13:00 Lunch Break

SECTION 2: Public-Private Partnerships? Global / Local Museum Centres
Chair: Georges Khalil (Berlin)

15:00 Oscar Salemink (Copenhagen)
City of Art: State, Market, Museums and the Urban Reinvention of Shanghai

15:30 Deepti Mulgund (New Dehli)
To the Nation, to the World? Two Moments of Museum-Making in India

16:00 Maurício Barros de Castro (Rio de Janeiro)
The Global/Local Power of the Inhotim Institute: contemporary art, and private museums in Brazil

16:30 Coffee Break


18:00 Wendy Shaw (Berlin)
Privatizing the Republic: Museums, Markets, and Global Ambitions in Contemporary Turkey

SATURDAY, 18/11/2017
Venue: Forum Transregionale Studien, Seminar Room, Wallotstraße 14, 14193 Berlin

10:00 Welcome and introduction:
Hannah Baader (Florenz / Berlin)
Georges Khalil (Berlin)

SECTION 3: Politics and Cultural Properties: Private Museums in Context
Chair: Hannah Baader (Florenz / Berlin)

10:15 Reema Salha Fadda (Oxford)
Towards a Transnational Museum? Negotiating the Political Economy of Cultural Production in Palestine

10:45 Mai Lin Tjoa-Bonatz (Frankfurt am Main) / Filemon Hulu (Gunungsitoli)
Manifestations of Cultural Property: Private Community Museums in Indonesia

11:15 Coffee Break

11:30 Peggy Levitt (Boston)
The Imagined Globe: Remapping the World Through Public Diplomacy at the Asia Society

12:00 Matthew Elliott Gillman (New York)
Custodians, Collections, Communities: The Aga Khan Museum in Toronto

12:30 Stephennie Mulder (Austin / Berlin)
Some Remarks on Private and Public Art Crime and Trade in Times of War

13:00 Close of the Symposium

Additional Information: Admission is free. No registration required but space is limited.